Woman’s tale of desperation beggars belief

• August 6, 2016

Woman’s tale of desperation beggars belief

An alleged scammer has been frequenting Ponsonby Road and its surrounds. Photo: Jessica-Belle Greer

A woman asking for money in central Ponsonby over the last few months has raised suspicions over her repeated pleas.

A recent post on community website Neighbourly, ‘Scam or lady in strife?’ has so far attracted 51 comments from locals who have been told the same story by a woman asking for cash.

Ponsonby regular Megan Annear recognised the image of the tall, middle-aged Pakeha woman on the social media post as someone who approached her outside Ponsonby Central around March this year.

“She walked right into the middle of our group of friends … and said ‘can I have some cash?’”

Just as the comments on Neighbourly noted, Miss Annear said the woman told them her abusive husband had just left her, her children were in her car down the road, and she needed cash to buy food.

Miss Annear said she and her partner thought the woman was genuine at first. But when they said they had no cash, the woman directed them to the nearby money machine.

When she asked them to get $40 instead of $20 out, the pair started to ask questions, and she became aggressive.

“She was really pissed off with us … we were quite scared. She’s quite an intimidating lady.”

Countdown on Willamson Ave

The alleged scammer has been seen outside Ponsonby Road and Countdown. Photo: Jessica-Belle Greer

Miss Annear then saw the woman approach an elderly man next to them.

“That made me really mad, as he was obviously not well off.”

Miss Annear said she saw the woman telling the same story on the same road four hours later.

“It’s really frustrating as we see so many people out there that need money… you want to trust the person.”

Retail worker Kirsten Pleitner was approached by a woman fitting the description outside Countdown on Williamson Ave around three weeks ago. She felt uneasy about the encounter.

The woman walked off when Miss Pleitner asked where her car and children were.

“She was obviously in a situation where she had to make up a story to get money off different people.”

Miss Pleitner said the incident made her feel “not great” because she usually gives donations to the homeless.

In an email, the police said: “We'd encourage anyone who feels that someone is behaving suspiciously to call the police or contact their local police station.”

Related Stories

Missing cow back safe and sound

Missing cow back safe and sound

James Beange • April 8, 2016

Orakei roosters ruffling residents' feathers

Orakei roosters ruffling residents' feathers

Millie McCaughan • June 7, 2016

​Self defence to the rescue for Onehunga women

​Self defence to the rescue for Onehunga women

Rosie Gordon • April 7, 2016

It's time to grow up, West Auckland

It's time to grow up, West Auckland

Toby Allen • November 9, 2020

Epsom woman left shaken after confrontation with an angry male pedestrian

Epsom woman left shaken after confrontation with an angry male pedestrian

Fravash Irani • May 9, 2024

Reliance on cars threatens Auckland’s emissions target

Reliance on cars threatens Auckland’s emissions target

Sophie Watson • May 9, 2023